Tuesday, May 7, 2024

ABCD: The All Bengal Crime Detectives by Suparna Chatterjee

Every so often, a new book feels familiar. The words bring back scenes from your childhood. The characters seem to be people you have seen or met - neighbours, relatives. A time machine in print. Suparna Chatterjee has managed to do that for me with her book "The All Bengal Crime Detectives". Set in a neighbourhood in South Kolkata where I grew up, all the characters seem so familiar. I managed to read through the book on Apple Books over a two week period - a welcome break from reading PowerPoints and annual reports of UK banks. I have shamefully lost my ability to read. There are so many distractions - Instagram reels, YouTube videos, WhatsApp notifications, emails, etc. The perils of reading in a world of notification nuisance. And to top it off, I was attempting to read on my phone - the hotbed of distractions. But I am glad I could finish it.

The cover on the edition I stumbled upon on Amazon UK (above) proclaimed "Combo of Blyton, Christie and Ray" - that piqued my interest. And the blurb on Amazon UK sealed the deal: "In a middle class Calcutta neighborhood, the lives of four recently retired men take an unexpected turn when they stumble upon a crime. Will the unlikely ‘detectives’ be able to catch the criminal? Or will they unravel something even more sinister? The Protagonists grab this exciting opportunity to rise above their mundane existence. They defy the ordinary, stretch their boundaries and in the process discover something precious. Meanwhile, a lot is going on in the Paara (neighborhood) a rather difficult match making process for a ‘whitish complexioned’ daughter, rivalry between two neighboring clubs over Durga Pujo, squabbles between the ‘ outdated’ seniors and the younger members of the local club, attempts at an impossible romance by a road side Romeo."

The four elderly gentlemen who meet in the morning at the park are the protagonists - three of them very middle class and the other a retired judge (so upper middle class) and the author has deftly delved in their personal lives (daily trips to the local bazaar, trying to find a match for their daughters, feeling slighted by the neighbourhood young men). And then there is the backdrop of the Pujo season. I had no idea when I picked up the book that it was set around our annual autumnal celebrations. The planning of the pujos, the inter-para rivalry, the chanda collection and the bhashaan dance - all wonderfully described. I highly recommend it to all of you pining for the South Kolkata at the turn of the millennium. 

PS: I suspect the title ABCD is a nod to Satyajit Ray's Feluda who was christened ABCD by Jatayu - Asia's Best Crime Detective!

The Hindu newspaper described the book as, “Suparna has crafted endearing stories of individual characters around the central story. Four recently retired men turn detectives when a robbery, involving them, occurs in their otherwise peaceful and friendly neighbourhood. While the four try to solve the case, other issues crop up: finding a perfect match for a dusky-complexioned girl and rivalry over organising Durga Puja are some of them.”


“I was sure I didn't want to write a stereotypical detective novel. I chose retired, middle class men as my main characters and not a smart, savvy detective.” A slight pause later, Suparna breaks into smiles. “The unlikeliest detective I could think of was my father. He has an eccentric sense of humour. His group of friends — incidentally all of them are avid bridge players — are equally interesting. I knew that by basing my characters on them, it would open up comic possibilities of epic proportions.”



Here's a bit more about the author:

Q: Could you tell us a bit about yourself?
A: I was born and brought up in Kolkata, though in the past ten years I have had the opportunity to live in the United States, France and Singapore before finally moving back to India again. Apart from writing, I enjoy traveling, music, art and meditation. I am a volunteer with the Art of Living Foundation. You will find more about me and my work on my blog.

Q: Can you tell us about your book, The All Bengali Crime Detectives. How did the idea come up?
A: I wanted to write a story about life in Kolkata, and write it in a way that it would make the city and her people seem familiar even to those who have never been there. I have lived in Kolkata for the first 24 years of my life, so I have had the privilege of experiencing the city’s culture firsthand. But the uniqueness and the sheer charm of it became apparent once I started living abroad. In many ways this book was an expression of the bottled-up nostalgia. I have always been a big fan of detective novels, and I thought that giving a crime angle would make the story even more interesting.

Q: What aspects of your book are new and unexpected for the mystery-loving reader?
A: The protagonists are not the smart, savvy, agile, confident detectives that one has come to expect in this genre. My detectives are not “professionals”. They are regular, every day people – endearing, vulnerable, excitable, and full of failings that make one human. Besides, unlike a classical detective story, in this book there are several other sub-plots brewing simultaneously, which are all equally important and which add up to give the readers a flavour of life in Kolkata.

Q: You mentioned in other interviews that life doesn’t tie things up, so you’ve deliberately left some story threads open in your book. Do you think this takes away from the murder mystery format, where the tendency is to tie everything up neatly?
A: The crime, and its subsequent investigation, does reach a logical end. Otherwise, it would make for a disappointing detective story! But some of the other threads have been left untied, as I feel that is a true reflection of life. Not everything always reaches a “logical” end in the same time frame. Life is a happening, and every event, situation, phase is complete in itself.

It’s like, you take a seed, and that seed is perfect, total, complete in itself. But that doesn’t mean it will not sprout and grow. It will become a sapling, which is also complete and perfect in itself. But again, it will grow in to a tree.

Q: Who are your idols in the genre? What other genres of writing do you enjoy reading?
A: Enid Blyton, Agatha Christie, Satyajit Ray. I also enjoy the works of Amitav Ghosh, Jhumpa Lahiri, Alexander McCall Smith, P.G. Wodehouse, as well as fantasy books like the Harry Potter or the Blart series.